Winehog - Burgundy with a passion

Burgundy Insights from the Winehog

Visit Domaine Georges Noëllat – tasting the 2018s from cask

By -

In the article about the 2015 vintage at Domaine Georges Noëllat, I wrote: “Immense talent and effortlessness …” This is still the theme of this article and my tasting of the 2018s.

I have followed Domaine Georges Noëllat since the 2012 vintage, and have been consistently amazed by the effortless nature of the wines from Maxime Cheurlin.

But something has changed in the recent years, as Maxime now is cooling the cellars to delay and slow down the malolactic fermentation. The first wines I experienced this with were from the 2017 vintage, and it required some adaptation of my schedule as a reviewer, as the wines did not finish malo until late summer or early fall 2018, almost a year after the harvest.

So this tasting of the 2018s – in July 2019 – is a bit premature, as most wines are still completing the latter part of their malolactic fermentation.

Late malolactic fermentation: effect?

I have followed Comte Georges de Vogüé for many years, and Francois Millet explains that the wines attain a greater precision and complexity when the malolactic fermentation is delayed by cooling them down in cask. The Vogüé wines normally complete their malo over the late summer as the air-conditioning is reduced.

Some producers have a cooler cellar and therefore slower malolactic fermentation naturally – Sebastien Cathiard sees malo completed the following fall for his slowest wines (usually the Malconsort). Amelie Berthaut is another producer with slow malolactic fermentations; hence tasting in summer is difficult.

Normally, this is how it is, and I have rarely comparatively tasted wines with early malo versus later. But it’s different in the case of Domaine Georges Noëllat, as I have tasted Maxime Cheurlin’s first vintages with early malo, and now the more recent vintages with later malo.

So what is the difference, based on my experience with the 2017s? In my very preliminary view, it seems the wines are a bit firmer and more precise with the later malo, and this could – perhaps – translate into more complexity. This is, however, very early and preliminary and does not signal a revolution, or even a revelation. But it is a step further in refining the wines.

The 2018s from Domaine Georges Noëllat

Based on the tasting done in July 2019 – mostly before finished malos – Maxime has refined his style, or should I say increased its precision. And with a vintage that resembles 2015, this is very interesting.

The wines are as always transparent, pure and intense in an effortless way; airy and almost silky with their refined expression being even more based on their individual terroirs.

The 2018s here are magnificent, and the weight of this warm year suits the estate style well, yet the wines will presumably require longer cellaring. Judging by Maxime Cheurlin’s 2015s, the 2018s will no doubt be in great demand.

Notes from the tasting on July 3, 2019

As mentioned, the wines are either at the end of their malo or somewhere in the middle, so conclusions and comments are necessarily preliminary.

The first wine, the Hautes Côtes de Nuits 2018, is still in early development with the malo not quite finished. It’s a delightfully fresh 2018 with cool fruit from the Curtil-Vergy area above Nuits-Saint-Georges. The nose offers cool, vivid fruit, indicating fine density. On the palate, good intensity and depth with fine energy for the vintage. The Hautes Côtes wines do shine in 2018 with their cool fruit. A delightful wine. Very Good – (87 – 88p).

—

Back to Vosne-Romanée, the Vosne-Romanee 2018 is an intense and vivid village, and quite a hedonistic treasure. On the bouquet, fine red fruit – raspberries, varieties of cherries and some fresh elements of redcurrant – with plenty of Vosne spices. On the palate, fine, delicate fruit that is weighty and precise with very good energy. I love the seductive, velvety character of these wines. Fine+ – (90 – 92p)



You need to login to read the rest of the artcle. If you are not a subscriber, use the subscribe function and sign-up.

Login

You need a Winehog subscription to see the rest of this article.
Login

Subscribe

You need a Winehog subscription to see the rest of this article.
Subscribe

Tasting Notes for this producer

Related articles

  • Visit to Domaine Georges Noëllat – tasting the 2019s from cask
    It seems that I am in a hurry. This was not originally my purpose in moving the Winehog base to Burgundy, but Covid has changed each and every plan I’ve made in the last 14 months. So let’s get down to business: the initial comments and notes on the Georges Noëllat 2019s. Delaying malo – a note Something ...
  • Visit Domaine Georges Noëllat – tasting the 2018s from cask
    In the article about the 2015 vintage at Domaine Georges Noëllat, I wrote: “Immense talent and effortlessness …” This is still the theme of this article and my tasting of the 2018s. I have followed Domaine Georges Noëllat since the 2012 vintage, and have been consistently amazed by the effortless nature of the wines from Maxime ...
  • Visit Domaine Georges Noëllat – tasting of the 2017s from Cask
    Domaine Georges Noëllat is one of my favourite estates these days – and it seems like Maxime Cheurlin is improving year after year. Wines are getting more detailed and the integration of the oak has improved over the years and is now seamless. The 2017s at Domaine Georges Noëllat is showing very well, as with other ...
  • Notes and comments to visits in May 2018
    The 2017s are showing beautifully in most cases – considering it’s rather early in the elevage. Malo in most cases were finished very or fairly early, and reds are given the nature of the vintage made with a rather light hand – also making the wines easier to taste at this stage. In my view it’s ...
  • Visit Domaine Georges Noëllat – tasting of the 2016s from Cask
    Domaine Georges Noëllat is one of my favourite estates these days – and it seems like Maxime Cheurlin is improving year after year. Wines are getting more detailed and the integration of the oak has improved over the years and is now seamless. Maxime and his neighbour Sebastien Cathiard are really upping the game – and ...

Vins d’émotion – wines that offer joy and hedonistic thrills

The principle with vins d’emotion is that they bring you extraordinary joy and hedonistic thrills.  A wine can be great, and at the same time not quite be a vin d’emotion.

All wines that evoke these emotional responses deserve a recommendation, and I have therefore created four levels of emotion recommendation: from the true and rare vin d’émotion to wines with some emotional potential.

A true vin d’émotion – a Burgundy of passion

A truly hedonistic wine – lively and enjoyable

A vivacious wine for pure indulgance

Check the full rating system
—

Read the original Vin d’émotion article here ..

Save 40% on the Winehog Premium subscription

Time to Subscribe?

Winehog offer - save 20%

€782 year
Two years with full access to Winehog
 
Sign up Now